No, I won't hit you. :-) Caviezel underplays a lot, and I can understand how some viewers might get a sleepwalking vibe. It's a style that doesn't suit everyone, but I personally like it.

"Man alive, it could have been amazing. If only they'd let me write it!"

I have thought that about SO many shows.

("LOST" was on choir night for me, so I never got into it. Though I have seen two or three episodes from way back in season one.)