I thought you might appreciate this: My two top seventh-grade classes get to read A Christmas Carol this time of year... On the first day of actual reading, one of my classes laughed -- nervously, at first, in a sort of shock -- because they weren't expecting Scrooge to be funny, and weren't sure if he was supposed to be funny, and weren't sure they were aloud to laugh at him -- at least once a page. You know, in the beginning, where Scrooge is being unbelievable unpleasant to everyone in sight. They thought it was "funnier than the Muppets version" (thank God! I'm not sure if I could have contained myself if they had said the reverse.)
Oh, I hope you can make time! That would be awesome! :-)
I love your students' reactions to the "Carol." It reminds me of Dorothy L. Sayers's reaction to Dante: that no one ever told her he was such a great storyteller! :-) The world in general does us such a disservice in painting the classics as these grim, intimidating books that everyone reveres but no one likes very much. I don't know how this attitude got so prevalent, but I wish it would go away!
no subject
Date: 2013-12-03 02:08 am (UTC)I thought you might appreciate this: My two top seventh-grade classes get to read A Christmas Carol this time of year... On the first day of actual reading, one of my classes laughed -- nervously, at first, in a sort of shock -- because they weren't expecting Scrooge to be funny, and weren't sure if he was supposed to be funny, and weren't sure they were aloud to laugh at him -- at least once a page. You know, in the beginning, where Scrooge is being unbelievable unpleasant to everyone in sight. They thought it was "funnier than the Muppets version" (thank God! I'm not sure if I could have contained myself if they had said the reverse.)
no subject
Date: 2013-12-03 03:12 am (UTC)I love your students' reactions to the "Carol." It reminds me of Dorothy L. Sayers's reaction to Dante: that no one ever told her he was such a great storyteller! :-) The world in general does us such a disservice in painting the classics as these grim, intimidating books that everyone reveres but no one likes very much. I don't know how this attitude got so prevalent, but I wish it would go away!
no subject
Date: 2013-12-04 02:44 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2013-12-04 03:58 am (UTC)